Nearly Every Child Left Behind
Skippy wrote some of this thoughts on what amounts to No Child Left Behind - our public schools’ proclivity for teaching to the standards set by the government for testing, and not teaching to practical life skills.
I have two thoughts on this topic:
Thought one:
In India, students (as many who are in physical proximity to their schools) are instructed in about 6th grade to decide on their future career, thus educational path. They are taught a minimum of what they need to know to move on to specialized areas of study. When they begin their lessons in their field of choice, they learn nothing outside of that field. For this reason, they excell in their areas of expertise, but can’t answer cross-vocational questions.
A prime example of this behavior was in one of the Indian software development contractors I worked with very briefly (before he ran off from his employer without a green card). He was a decent programmer, but he had to be instructed explicitly what to do. He was unable to make intuitive leaps in his functional coding because the matter of the project was completely outside of his scope of knowledge. My experience with this one contractor has been my general experience with off-shore contracting in India, where their affectation for specifications seems admirable at first, but then you come to realize that without that explicit and thorough direction, they can make no judgement of their own.
You might think waiting for input from the employer to be a virtue at first, but in an organization that stops working entirely when they can’t make an intuitive guess of what their employer might want - to be sorted out later - the half-planet time delay becomes a significant factor. “You did not work today because you could not take a guess as to what we would like for a UI and decided to wait for our input?” Yeah, no.
Without a well-rounded education, like that which American universities provide, schools that provide career directed or core-proficiency directed instruction will result in less proficient workers.
